Revisiting Winston Mahabir’s In and Out of Politics
Revisiting Winston Mahabir’s In and Out of Politics
Political memoir is an inherently suspect genre. Often an attempt to cash in on political clout, an empty exercise in legacy building, or an advertisement for a politician’s latest gambit, these books are hardly seen as a reliable historical record and regularly meet warranted wariness among readers. At the same time, they conjure appeal through their trade in gossip, once privileged information, and personal divulgences. Their capacity for retrospection and reflection also adds to their pull. In offering personalized narration of political phenomena, however, political memoirs find order and intention in honest and dishonest ways. As George Egerton notes in “Politics and Autobiography,” the genre risks reducing historical processes to the choices of remarkable individuals. Even though he considers the genre favorably, Egerton suggests that political memoir may “perfor[m] an essentially conservative function by enhancing and legitimating the status and role of leaders.”1 One therefore reads for the memoirist’s candor just as one reads for the genre’s distortions.
The memoir of concern in this essay is Winston Mahabir’s In and Out of Politics, published in 1978.2 I was returned to it by Ryan Cecil Jobson’s recent piece, “Radiation and the Question of Power.” Jobson considers the spread of rumors of radiation in Trinidad and Tobago after the construction of a radar station in 1958 at the US Navy base in Chaguaramas. This episode followed the 1956 electoral victory of Eric Williams’s newly formed People’s National Movement (PNM). Jobson focuses on C. L. R. James’s coverage of the radiation issue as editor of the PNM newspaper, The Nation, identifying James’s desire to “exalt the radiation saga as a foundational expression of working-class self-organization in the West Indies.” In and Out came to mind because Mahabir presents the issue quite differently, discussing it instead in terms of gullibility. Jobson’s consideration of “political facts” via James is more advantageous than Mahabir’s framing, which left me wondering as to the position Mahabir’s memoir now holds within the field of Caribbean literature, nearly fifty years after its publication.3
Though it may be an overstatement to say that political memoirs and autobiographies became de rigueur in the decades following independence, Mahabir was not alone in this endeavor. Williams’s Inward Hunger appeared in 1969 and was followed by Albert Gomes’s Through a Maze of Colour in 1974 and Patrick Solomon’s Solomon, an Autobiography in 1981. Solomon and Mahabir were published by Inprint Caribbean, which was founded by Owen Baptiste and his wife, Rhona Baptiste, and whose legacy merits its own consideration. Owen Baptiste offers a publisher’s note to In and Out, recalling that he was at first dismissive of Mahabir because he deemed him “a former PNM Minister, who in 1962, the year of our independence, had thought it wiser to flee than to stay” (xiii). Baptiste is referring to the fact that Mahabir participated in the founding of the PNM, with Williams as its leader, and upon their victory Mahabir served as Trinidad and Tobago’s health minister from 1956 to 1961. After those five years, Mahabir decided against continuing as a politician and moved with his family to Vancouver, Canada. His connection to Vancouver was longstanding—he first met his wife, Joan Graham, there in 1950. As noted in his obituary in The Globe and Mail, he studied and taught at the University of British Columbia, and he practiced medicine and psychiatry in Vancouver and then in Victoria, where he died in 2003.4 It is from Canada that he produced In and Out, and Baptiste admits that he later grew appreciative of Mahabir’s perspective, describing Mahabir’s memoir as avoiding bitterness while still taking Williams’s leadership to task.
At the start of In and Out, Mahabir explicitly expresses his intention as politician turned author: “It was Christ’s apostles who immortalized Him. The reverse seems necessary with Williams. His apostles have a duty to mortalize him, to write about the man they knew, even if they themselves are destined to be regarded by posterity as noteless blots on a remembered name” (2). Here, Mahabir positions himself as party to Williams’s political ascension and as skeptic of the messianic mythmaking that goes into constructing the father of the nation. In describing himself as an apostle with a duty and as a noteless blot, Mahabir also steeps In and Out in both self-aggrandizement and self-effacement. This approach holds true for the entire book, since Mahabir tends to cite the power he wielded while downplaying his overall import by consistently turning to the more significant Williams. The result is a portrait of Williams as a brilliant, inspiring scholar and politician who was also capricious, snide, and arrogant. Mahabir casts himself as ideally suited to perform this evaluation: He knew Williams during his stint at the Anglo-American Caribbean Commission (later the Caribbean Commission), and he was a confidante after Williams’s dismissal in 1955. Mahabir’s home in San Fernando was, in his view, “the birth-place of the PNM” (25). He was there for the PNM’s victory in the 1956 council elections and their loss in the 1958 federal elections. With In and Out fitting into the significant body of work devoted to assessing Williams’s contentious legacy, Mahabir’s momentary closeness to Williams may recommend In and Out to some, just as it might warn away others.
Readers can glean from In and Out information about lesser discussed aspects of Trinidad and Tobago’s political landscape in the late 1950s and early 1960s. While glimpses of Latin America and South Asia are offered as Mahabir recalls his diplomatic trips, In and Out more extensively covers his varied contributions to nation-building projects. He highlights the needs of Trinidad and Tobago, particularly in terms of public health, and offers sketches of contemporaries, like Learie Constantine and Bhadase Sagan Maraj. The roots of the PNM are also explored via Mahabir’s description of the study group Bachacs, founded by him, Ibbit Mosaheb, and Williams in 1954. Because this group provided half of the first PNM cabinet, it is useful to note that the study group’s intent was to mimic the capacity of bachacs, a type of ant, to use collective effort “to destroy healthy plants—especially imported rose bushes” (17). Mahabir cites the betrayal of this collective ethos in explaining his break from Williams in 1961. In describing Williams’s choice to sever ties with C. L. R. James, Mahabir asks, “Does Williams care at all about people apart from their value as manipulable political objects?” (70). Mahabir describes this paranoid, self-serving disposition as the “complete reversal of Bachac tradition, which was to destroy in order to build” (71).
In and Out also sheds light on connections between the Caribbean and Canada during the 1940s, with specific emphasis on McGill University. While studying sociology at McGill, Mahabir found community with other Caribbean students, and Williams became an important point of focus. Brinsley Samaroo briefly examines this history in his essay “Eric Williams, the Bibliophile and the Scholar.” In discussing Williams’s bibliophilia, Samaroo details Williams’s interest in McGill. He explains that during WWII, Caribbean students chose McGill University “as a replacement for the Oxbridge universities,” and by the “mid-1940s there were about 200 West Indians at McGill.”5 These students formed the British West Indian Society (BWIS). Williams knew a few of these students who took preliminary courses at Howard University where he taught, and he was in correspondence with them.
Drawing perhaps on their shared relation as scholarship boys from Queen’s Royal College in Trinidad, Mahabir also wrote to Williams while at McGill. “Our personal relationship continued unabated during my years at McGill,” Mahabir explains (14). These exchanges drew Williams closer to Canada. Eventually, the BWIS, with Mahabir serving as vice president, hosted Williams in April 1945. Samaroo details this visit: “During that week Williams spoke to the BWIS, the Political Science Department at McGill, the British West Indian Study Group, and the Canadian public. He was also the keynote speaker and principal discussant at a two-day education conference in Montreal.”6 Samaroo presents this visit as informing Williams’s educational platform in his subsequent political campaigns and as solidifying relationships with individuals who later aided in the formation of the PNM. Williams’s impact on the BWIS and McGill seems similarly noteworthy. While the significance of Montreal and McGill as sites of Black community organization, Black diasporic exchange, and anti-Black repression has been explored in books like David Austin’s Fear of a Black Nation and rosalind hampton’s Black Racialization and Resistance at an Elite University, the confluence of relationships entwining the BWIS, Williams, and McGill in the 1940s has not received much critical attention.7 In and Out offers useful provocations toward pursuing that history.
In and Out also presents opportunities to consider race relations in Trinidad and Tobago. When Mahabir returned to Trinidad in 1950 to establish his medical practice in San Fernando, he aided in Williams’s transition into political campaigner. After the PNM’s launch, Mahabir stood for office in the San Fernando West constituency, earning the nickname “Silvertongue” for his oratory. Nonetheless, his involvement with the PNM raised the ire of a subset of East Indians. He explains that he and Kamaluddin Mohammed “were both regarded by certain Indians as some special breed of traitors to the ‘Indian cause,’ since [they] chose to serve in a party led by an African and with a dominantly African membership” (31). Mahabir was keenly aware of this fact while steadfast in his commitment to the principles of the party he helped found. Mahabir also discusses Williams’s infamous speech regarding that “‘hostile and recalcitrant minority’” (78). This was immediately after the 1958 federal elections. Williams followed his disappointment with the results of those elections by lashing out against East Indians. Mahabir describes those statements as evidencing Williams’s “gross emotional instability” and reflecting “his personality’s deficient ability to accommodate setbacks of any kind” (80). Considering race relations in this era involves much more than what In and Out offers, but it is useful to note that Mahabir consistently broaches the matter in terms of the personality defects of Williams.
Mahabir’s approach is the same when he interrogates the positioning of Chinese Trinidadians. In terms of the involvement of this demographic in governance, Solomon Hochoy is given significant attention, with Mahabir admiring him as “one of the most astute persons in the world of Caribbean politics” (60). There are also fleeting references to Mayleen Mook Sang and the intrigue surrounding her marriage to Williams. Mahabir befriended her while at McGill and describes her as a “prominent, if evanescent, figure in Trinidad politics” (13). More significantly, Mahabir considers Williams’s attitude to Chinese Trinidadians, with Mahabir presenting them as under suspicion, if not threat, whenever Williams was in a state of paranoia. Mahabir claims that “Williams exhibited marked ambivalence towards the Chinese” in Trinidad and Tobago (60). Mahabir’s observations match in some ways the scholarship on this topic. In “Images of the Chinese in West Indian History,” for example, Walton Look Lai asserts that while individuals of Chinese descent participated in regional nationalist movements, “one of the consequences of the society’s ambivalence toward the Chinese middlemen in an age of anticolonialism has been the sporadic outburst of animosity toward them.” This dynamic is what Mahabir recounts in In and Out. Yet Mahabir’s writing also displays “ignorance about who the Chinese were as a group,” another tenet that Look Lai identifies as definitive of representations of this demographic across eras.8 Bringing perspectives from this population to bear on Mahabir’s writing would sharpen our understanding of these formative decades while also furthering Look Lai’s project of determining how Caribbean writers and politicians alike invoke this minority to their own ends.
There are a few characteristics of In and Out that are off-putting. In attempting to replicate picong in his writing, Mahabir comes across, at times, as charmed by his own wit. He appears oblivious to the chauvinistic undertones of certain recollections, and his overall inattention to the role of women in this era is conspicuous. In and Out has also come under suspicion because of its handling of the radiation matter earlier mentioned. Facts uncovered by Colin A. Palmer in Eric Williams and the Making of the Modern Caribbean suggest duplicity. Referring to archived official communications, Palmer explains that “in mid-July [of 1959], after a trip to the United Kingdom, Mahabir informed the Cabinet that he was firmly convinced that the presence of a US base in Trinidad ‘involved our population in hazards over which a Minister of Health has no control.’”9 Palmer claims that in In and Out Mahabir denies these facts in order to downplay his involvement in the radiation saga.
In my view, the timeline here is a bit confused. In In and Out, Mahabir suggests Williams overstepped in April 1959 in that “he announced in highly dramatic fashion [at Woodford Square] that he had substantial evidence of Radiation being used by the Americans at Chaguaramas” (83). Mahabir and others balked at this and confronted Williams. After discord and then reconciliation, Mahabir was sent to England. His priority was extracting a guarantee of independence, but he was also cognizant of the fact that Grantley Adams, as leader of the federal government, “wanted to make the issue of the American presence in the Caribbean a federal matter,” which Williams and Mahabir were opposed to (85). In a guarded manner, Mahabir refers in In and Out to a letter he sent to Williams from England once he learned that there was no opposition to independence. Given that Palmer cites communication from Mahabir in mid-July, it seems plausible that Mahabir changed strategies between April and July to satisfy political goals. He was likely not being disingenuous in In and Out when he said that when listening to Williams’s speech in April, he “did not know whether to laugh at him or cry for the gullible crowd which was being ultraviolated” (83). That said, researchers with access to the documents in question are obviously in a better position to judge Mahabir’s telling in In and Out.
My intent in this essay has not been to rehabilitate In and Out as a trove of truths. Indeed, I remain leery of this memoir as with any political memoir. While useful, it seems clear that to read In and Out is to risk imbibing a version of Trinidad and Tobago’s history that positions the charismatic male politician over and above the significance of the laboring masses. That perspective has been overdone, which is why Jobson’s approach is welcome. It is not that Mahabir is oblivious or counterpoised to these masses. In fact, many times throughout In and Out he expresses his belief that Williams’s trajectory as leader went awry when he stopped attending to them. Yet, as Egerton explains, the nature of the political memoir nudges the memoirist into savoring or ruing the choices of empowered individuals to the extent that alternative chronologies are cast aside. Nearly fifty years later, In and Out remains worthy of study as long as we meet it for what it is rather than what we would like it to be.
Kris Singh is a faculty member in the English Department at Kwantlen Polytechnic University, Surrey, British Columbia. His scholarly and creative attention spans the legacy of indentureship, identity production in the Caribbean diaspora, and the place of technology in Caribbean literature. His recent scholarship can be found in Archipelagos: A Journal of Caribbean Digital Praxis, Anthurium: A Caribbean Studies Journal, and The Journal of West Indian Literature. His creative work has previously appeared in sx salon, PREE, and The Ex-Puritan.
[1] George Egerton, “Politics and Autobiography: Political Memoir as Polygenre,” Biography 15, no. 3 (1992): 238.
[2] Winston Mahabir, In and Out of Politics: Tales of the Government of Dr. Eric Williams from the Notebooks of a Former Minister (Inprint Caribbean, 1978). Hereafter cited in the text.
[3] Ryan Cecil Jobson, “Radiation and the Question of Power: C. L. R. James and the Struggle for Chaguaramas,” Small Axe, no. 78 (November 2025): 47, 52.
[4] Tom Hawthorn, “Winston Mahabir 1921–2003: B.C. Doctor Helped Build Trinidad,” The Globe and Mail, 24 November 2003.
[5] Brinsley Samaroo, “Eric Williams, the Bibliophile and Scholar,” Journal of Caribbean History 37, no. 2 (2003): 281.
[6] Samaroo, “Eric Williams,” 282.
[7] David Austin, Fear of a Black Nation: Race, Sex, and Security in Sixties Montreal (Between the Lines, 2013); rosalind hampton, Black Racialization and Resistance at an Elite University (University of Toronto Press, 2020).
[8] Walton Look Lai, “Images of the Chinese in West Indian History,” in Wanni W. Anderson and Robert G. Lee, eds., Displacements and Diasporas: Asians in the Americas (Rutgers University Press, 2005): 74, 69.
[9] Colin A. Palmer, Eric Williams and the Making of the Modern Caribbean (University of North Carolina Press, 2008), 121.