The Jamaican State and Reparations
The Jamaican State and Reparations
[This essay will be published as the preface to Small Axe 82, available March 2027]
I have lamented (late in 2026, when this is being written) what seems to me the revealing contradiction between, on the one hand, the Jamaican state’s loud breast-thumping declarations of its commitment to seeking reparations for the historical wrong of colonial slavery and, on the other hand, the fact that while other nations (including many Caribbean ones) walked out of the United Nations chamber of the General Assembly meeting on 24 September 2026, when Israel’s prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, a declared war criminal remember, mounted the podium to make his address, Jamaica’s representatives remained complacently seated. As though the genocide of Palestinians in Gaza and the continued illegal annexation of land in the West Bank (not to mention the founding atrocity, the Nakba) were not the most recent instantiations of the same colonial process of systematic violence and dispossession and apartheid of which the genocide of our Native peoples, and the kidnapping, transshipment, and enslavement of Africans, was an inaugural world-historical moment. Almost forty-eight years ago to the day, 11 October 1978, Michael Manley made an unforgettable address to that very chamber expressing Jamaica’s unstinting solidarity with the struggles against apartheid in South Africa because this was inseparable from the ongoing struggle of Caribbean people for self-determination and social justice. What makes it possible for our current political elites, the now-privileged descendants of those enslaved Africans in whose name they speak, to pride themselves on their discovery of reparations as their new potential source of development funding, while at the same time remaining silent on the plight of Palestinians? What is the moral cost of such compromise?
Let me be absolutely clear, colonial slavery was a moral evil, a wrong of such magnitude, prolonged for so long, and then treated with such racist indifference, that there can in fact be no repair, only more or less ameliorative gestures whose form and scale is—or should be—a matter not of legal-diplomatic resolution but of moral-political debate and organized struggle in local, regional, and global fora. New World slavery inflicted a racial wound that cannot heal and whose consequences Black and White humanity will have to live with forever. This is the argument of my book Irreparable Evil.
The Jamaican state takes a different view. It believes that reparations can be won by appealing to the British monarch—now that it appears that the direct path to the International Court of Justice has been blocked by the British state on the grounds that it only accepts the jurisdiction of the court for cases arising after 1974, and even then only if they do not involve Commonwealth or former Commonwealth countries. 2 In a clever legal maneuver, meant to circumvent the roadblocks thrown up by successive British governments, the Jamaican state activated Section 4 of the Judicial Committee Act 1833 that empowers the reigning sovereign to refer seemingly intractable legal or constitutional matters directly to the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council (which is, of course, independent Jamaica’s final court of appeal) for hearing and advisory opinion. Thus in September 2026 the Minister of Culture, the Honorable Olivia “Babsy” Grange, led the Jamaican delegation to London to present a petition to King Charles III, independent Jamaica’s formal head of state. The petition seeks the king’s guidance on three questions: Was the forced transportation of Africans to Jamaica for the purpose of their enslavement lawful? Did such enslavement constitute a crime against humanity? Is Britain under an obligation to provide restitution for this past atrocity and its enduring consequences? On 23 September a triumphant Grange announced in Jamaica’s parliament that, indeed, the good king had referred the matter to the Privy Council and that in fact, the week of 8 March 2027 was now set for the hearing of the petition. As the exultant Grange declared, the king has not ignored us.
Of course, historically, in Jamaica (and the wider anglophone Caribbean), petitioning British monarchs for redress is a familiar mode of moral appeal. But recently Sir Hilary Beckles, the distinguished chairperson of the Caribbean Community Reparations Commission and a tireless campaigner for the reparations cause, has opted for a more personalized approach to reparations diplomacy. Speaking at a press conference ahead of the November 2026 Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting (CHOG) in Antigua and Barbuda, Beckles addressed King Charles not as the reigning monarch and head of the Commonwealth but as a “human brother” whose family benefitted from the traffic in, and enslavement of, Africans: “I’m appealing to Charles Windsor, a parent, a grandparent, a man today who reflects upon the history of his family, and can see the enrichment that slavery provided to his family.” It may be a tribute to Sir Hilary that he keeps such faith in the monarch’s humanity. Predictably, however, at the CHOG meeting, the good king offered no more than a familiar mawkish platitude: “As I have said before, that shameful chapter of history is one that fills my heart with horror and my soul with the most profound personal sorrow.”
The frustration Beckles clearly feels at the stonewalling disavowals of the British state is matched by his exasperation at the casuistry of British academics. Now, the driving argument upon which Beckles’s reparatory justice claim rests is that New World slavery has always been recognized as a crime, a universal crime but one that until the early nineteenth century suited the British national interest. However, this view has not received widespread support from British historians. In a recent episode of Aljazeera’s Inside Story devoted to the question, “Does the UK have a legal obligation to redress the harms of slavery?,” the emeritus fellow of St Peter’s College, Oxford University, Lawrence Goldman (appearing along with Beckles and Patrick Vernon, a member of the Global Jamaica Diaspora Council), objected to Beckles’s argument on the grounds that it was anachronistic; there was no recognized international law at the time that defined slavery as a crime, much less a crime against humanity. Furthermore, he insisted, present-day British taxpayers could not be held responsible for the actions of their forebears and be expected to pay reparations to the descendants of the enslaved (even though British taxpayers paid reparations to the slaveowners in 1834). This, incidentally, is also the view of the current British prime minister, Andy Burnham, who says that while he is contemplating a formal apology for Britain’s participation in the slavery business, there is no chance of reparations. Goldman, moreover, goes on to claim, much to the evident chagrin of the impatiently listening Beckles, that far from being the moral agent of unsurpassed wickedness, it was the “great achievement” of the British that they outlawed slave trafficking in 1807 and slavery itself in 1833. Echoing the self-congratulatory sentiments of the legendary apologist Sir Reginal Coupland, the British should be thanked, not vilified. So far as Goldman is concerned, contemporary Britons are unimplicated in Britain’s past evils; their current prosperity bears no relation to the persistent poverty of Caribbean states. The British state has done its duty, and it is now time to put this whole regrettable historical episode to rest (with the good will proviso, of course, that Britain stands prepared to help Jamaica where possible with specific development matters). In the face of such self-righteous speciousness, it is easy to appreciate Beckles’s head-shaking expression of dismay. Disavowal, after all, is one of the passive-aggressive modes of contemporary British racism.
I profoundly sympathize with Beckles’s outrage at historians like Goldman, but as I have argued in Irreparable Evil I disagree with his historical interpretation of the past and the legal- diplomatic implications about reparations he draws from it. Now, to be sure, the Jamaican state’s legal strategy shows a certain diplomatic astuteness, a canny way of maneuvering around the sophistry of the British state. And I certainly hope that the Privy Council outcome is favorable to Jamaica’s cause. It would be a momentous occasion indeed for the Caribbean if the British state were obliged to admit that its participation in the institution of slavery was such as to require it to pay reparations. But I am not persuaded that this is a path that, even if successful on its own terms (receipt, for example, of the US$10 billion Jamaica is demanding), would result in meaningful change in the lives of ordinary Black Jamaicans, the descendants of those for whom, after all, reparatory justice is being sought.
Briefly stated, the contrary view I hold is that reparatory justice worth the name needs to be made a constituent part less of a legal-diplomatic negotiation than of a political struggle—a political struggle for social-economic-political transformation inscribed and enacted at various scales simultaneously: national, regional, and global. Therefore, in the first place, it needs to be part of a struggle for the transformation of the social-economic-political order in Jamaica and the wider Caribbean—that is, a transformation at the level both of the organization of the production and distribution of social wealth (that foregrounds the interests and demands of the Black working poor), and of the organization of political participation (such that the Black majority have a central voice in political decision-making). This register of political struggle for transformation, moreover, has to be a constituent part of a global struggle that joins in solidarity with cognate struggles for social, economic, and political transformation, such as those of Palestinians for self-determination and the repossession of their stolen lands and forms of life. This orientation, needless to say, is not one that is likely to be favorable to the governing elites of the Jamaican state. Understandably, they have too much to lose; they are too compromised; they are too entrenched in the political and economic order they declare themselves to be opposed.
Johannesburg—New York,
October—November 2026
— David Scott