They said the fourth child, George, was the one who resembled his mother the most. No matter what they did he wouldn’t fall quiet, crying hours into his new life. When finally he stopped, it was only to stare wide-eyed through the candlelight up to the ceiling instead of shutting his eyes and going to sleep like his sisters and brother on either side of him. The house went to bed before he did, and when it woke again he had his eyes opened still, never shutting them it seemed. It took his mother a full day before she saw him sleep.
They said, like his mother, it was the Amerindian blood in him, protesting against the union of races. His great-great-grandfather, a Carib war chief, had spent his entire life rebuffing the encroaching Spanish, giving his daughter to a Dutchman to be married with the understanding that it would draw members from either side closer in the fight against their common enemy. Only for the man’s grand-daughter (the boy’s grandmother), along with dozens more of their people, to get herself baptized and put herself in a monastery run by Spanish monks.
He must have turned in his grave. Only to turn around again with a smile when mistakes were made, some boundary crossed or slight taken heavily (none of the Spanish settlers knew exactly why), and one of the Amerindians loosed an ancient war-cry, bringing the entire camp, including George’s grandmother, down on the monks in a confusion of poisoned arrows and sharpened implements.
When they captured the boy’s grandmother she was shown no mercy. She, like her husband and all others in the attack, was punished with death for her crimes, but George’s mother, then only an innocent toddler, was spared. They threw her out of the monastery, though, with a letter to the family that took her in, warning against the “rebellious, cannibalistic tendencies” of her ancestors, the Native peoples. They took the child and burned the letter. She grew up beautiful, and although only a small percentage of her ancestors were White, no one ever questioned her connection to her adoptive parents. She married young and she married rich, to an older man who grew sugarcane on the estate he owned, giving birth to quadruplets within the first four months of their marriage and dying only hours after watching her last son, George, close his eyes and rest for the first time. So they said.
The boy’s sisters grew up, got married, and left. His father died of old age and perhaps grief at the passing of his only other son. George took over the running of the estate. He was married with children, however, by the time he fell in love with one of the Indian laborers who worked on the plantation. Just as he was as a newborn, he was in his adult life, barely sleeping when night came. He sat on his porch in the early hours of the morning, watching the silhouettes of the indentured laborers file past the house into the cane fields as they started the day’s work and told himself he could tell the woman he loved apart from all the others, even in the dark.
When she worked where he could see her, George sat in his chair and watched until the sun set and the workers left for their barracks, longing rippling through his body as he observed her sinewy grace and the evenness of her sweat-glistened skin shining in the sun. He had the feeling that he was a cup filling up, and now the liquid in him was past brimming and held together at the top only by surface tension. The porch faced east, the fields were expansive and flat, and when the sun rose he leaned back further into the slim shadow cast by the roof and squinted out at the figures bent over near the canes or walking among them.
On a day during crop season, several months after his wife had started disappearing into illness like his brother, he was sitting like that, quietly watching them work. The overseer in the fields was watching, too, mounted on his horse. In the periphery of his vision, George saw him dismount suddenly, stride over to the woman of faultless beauty and, like he was trying to kick open a door, raise a boot and bring it down on her back.
As she went down George flew up off his chair. “Dawson!” he shouted (that was the overseer’s name). But he was too far away and couldn’t be heard. He stepped down off the porch, livid with himself about the incompetent he had hired. Her husband never worked in her gang, and no one else raised a protest, looking away warily, afraid that Dawson might turn his attention their way. True, he knew Dawson had a temper and had noticed a few blows here and there, but the brute had gone too far. He had only gotten a little way from the house, though, when Dawson finished shouting at her and moved away. He stopped and turned around, considering now how his reaction might be viewed.
The decision he made initially was to leave it alone, but that didn’t stop him from tensing up every time he saw Dawson approach her or stare at her for a moment too long. It took him six days to come up with a solution and eight to implement it. When the laborers were heading home on that eight day he walked down to meet her, stopping her. He put the offer forward of bringing her into his house to be his children’s nanny. She looked at him coolly and said nothing. He told her how much she would be paid and she nodded quickly in agreement. The next day, when she showed up at the door of his house, he asked her name.
It was Lakshmi. He tried to convert her to Christianity in her first few days, and she dodged him with an assortment of evasions so oblique George gave up immediately. Regardless, she turned out to be a competent nanny. She had three children of her own, after all, and during her time working as the nanny she became pregnant with her fourth. This worried her husband—another mouth to feed. It only got worse later, finding himself thrown into a short-lived bout of depression when the baby was born fair-skinned and light-eyed, and he looked at his own brown skin, looked at his wife’s brown skin, and thought next to where she worked.
She told him that she had ancestors from Kashmir where the Indians were light-skinned and tall and explained that the color was only just being passed down, having skipped a couple of generations. The lie made him feel better because he had something to tell others and, because his spirits were lifted slightly, he took time to remind himself that his wife made more money than he did and so he shouldn’t upset her. But what really changed his mind about his situation was the extent to which their treatment on the plantation was improved after the child was born. His wife also tended to now bring home little gifts from the house.
She worked as a nanny for twelve more years after that but never again had reason to make a claim on her ancestry, her only other child looking like all the rest. But it was that fourth child, whom they had named, Sookia, who caused all the trouble in the family, ten years younger than her oldest brother and two years older than her youngest. She was the only girl and seemed to recognize, on some deep fundamental level, that she was different. She was bad-tempered and mischievous, never listening to her parents a day in her life. By the time the estate owner’s children grew too old for a nanny and her mother returned to cutting cane, she had become completely unmanageable. Yes, she could prepare the roti, make the talkari and dahl, but she also later developed the tendency to disappear from among the rest of the family without a trace for hours. A tendency that infuriated her father and was the cause of the appearance of a band of grey hairs just above her mother’s left ear. So, she said.
The family had grown, two of her brothers marrying and having children and now living together with their wives on the compound, and so at first it was easy enough to slip away with all the extra bodies to keep track of, but when they took notice and begun to realize that the disappearances wouldn’t stop on their own, they decided to put one of her brothers’ wives to watch her. The wife was pregnant and so was well suited to the role of sitting around the house and making sure Sookia didn’t get herself into any trouble, but after she had the baby it was implicitly understood within the family that Sookia’s duty was to now make sure she always cast a watchful eye over her niece. She needed no encouragement, though. She was absolutely entranced by observing her niece as she grew. When she watched over her, she often did so deep in thought. Looking at her complexion and reminded of her own difference, Sookia was intrigued that her niece was perceived to age gradually before suddenly advancing in leaps: from one day old to two days old, for example. But at points there were subtle shifts where it was no longer adequate to measure her in weeks but months, or months but years, and that became what she was: two years old, regardless of the interstices. Contiguity had been made into rigid order.
The new role as watchful eye worked well; she stopped running off, and they thought collectively that they had finally managed to mold her into a decent young Indian girl. That is until they informed her that they had arranged a marriage for her with an Indian boy from another community. She seemed to reject the idea instinctively. It took days of arguing, hands flying, insults being flung back and forth in Hindi, before she finally told them flat, if she had to marry anybody she didn’t know, she would secretly put poison in his food to make him sick. Her brothers and their wives gave her scathing looks of reproach, her father fell curiously silent, and her mother fell ill for three weeks, unable to do anything but the most basic tasks.
The marriage arrangement was broken and the family settled into an impasse, where they didn’t make any mention of marriage and she went about her duties without complaint or incident. But just after she turned twenty-four she somehow managed to disappear again, this time not returning. It took the family days of searching before they found out where she had gone, and then they decided it hadn’t been worth the effort. She had moved across the city, they heard, and was now living with a Black man, a Christian. Immediately she was disowned and encouraged to be forgotten. Her mother found herself bedridden for five weeks.
On the day of her departure she had taken up a few of her possessions and left. She had been so desperate to leave she had walked most of the way without food or money, past carts pulled by bison along roads fenced by head-height strands of grass that were bent one way and then the other by the wind. She knew exactly where she was going, and arriving at his home told him that she wasn’t going back and that he would have to marry her. They got married because he wanted to and because she wanted to escape her family and the life she had become accustomed to.
She slipped seamlessly into his life. He was a teacher and left home to travel to a remote village in Trinidad regularly and for extended periods. In his absence, she took care of his mother and grandmother, and when his grandmother died soon after she arrived, she started growing crops for sale on the land her husband owned. They had four children, the first and the last eight years apart, and it was the last, Blaze, whom she loved the most and who loved her the most. Her husband passed away long before her, and Blaze was the one who took it upon himself to make her funeral arrangements when she died on the day of her fiftieth birthday, as though she had grown tired and had decided it was about time to move on. He tended to have dreams that he felt were part a reading of the future and part potential creative expression and, in this way, had seen it coming. When he visited her that day, he found her lying motionless in bed and knew that she was gone.
By that time he was working as a railway repairman for little pay and poor treatment, but he had a positive outlook on life that couldn’t be swayed. Partly because he always had Carnival to look forward to. He couldn't find that kind of excitement in his job. Although he was partial to the broadening of his chest and thickening of his muscles he gained from the physical labor of hauling steel rails around, there were parts of his job—injuries and the occasional death—that he suppressed almost as soon as he witnessed them. He freed himself from this trauma on Carnival Monday and Tuesday and by Ash Wednesday; the excitement of the previous two days would get into him and he would go to bed with thoughts of the next year’s celebration in mind. He had a friend who spent his time experimenting with old steel drums, trying to turn them into musical instruments. He would encourage him—“Y’ have to come to the panyard an’ listen to this t’ing play, man. I’s sweet music. Sweet, sweet music”—and although he couldn’t escape the music when the instruments became popular, he never did join his friend.
He was too busy. He had a child to take care of and was about to start his first marriage. He switched jobs, moving from the railways to the docks, loading and unloading ships that came in and went out. He had two more children, then got divorced, leaving his wife and children and all designs on marriage behind him. Returning only on occasion to drop money off for the children to buy their schoolbooks or clothing or food.
He never got married again, but he did settle down to live with a woman after that. It didn’t last, ending soon after she found out about the other family he paid frequent (to her) visits to. Not to forget that he disappeared over the Carnival period, and who knew what he did then or who he did it with. They had two children together by the time the relationship ended. Two children he barely knew, since she threatened him with his life if he ever stepped foot in her house again.
The next relationship he had lasted the longest, a total of nineteen years, producing two more children. It was by far the most stable period in his life. He switched from working on the docks to working on a cocoa plantation. He was getting older and Carnival took less of a central role in his life, instead turning his focus on taking care of the latest two children. The relationship went smoothly for most of the nineteen years it lasted. There was a hiccup when she found out about the other five children he had and another when she realized he had no intention of marrying her, but the relationship ended only when a question of his fidelity was raised and she discovered that he had slept with at least two other women while they were together.
She confronted him when he came home from work. He lied and said it wasn’t true. She picked up a broom and beat him with the end used for sweeping because she knew that it was. The children cried and were forgotten in the fight, going to bed hungry and miserable. When they woke again, they did it thankfully without the knowledge that their father had been put out once by their mother only to storm his way back in because the house was his. So they couldn’t really comprehend what she was planning when she woke them before the crack of dawn, telling them to bathe and get dressed when they were both on vacation from school. She took them to live with their grandmother and never returned.
He had switched jobs again by that time, a friend convincing him that he should work in construction and later getting him started. When the government decided it needed to build two towers in Port of Spain to house some of its ministries he managed to find work on his first major project.
His work life had progressed, but after three failed attempts he gave up on starting a family, although there were women that still came in and went out of his life. He died suddenly at seventy-one, having fathered children well into his sixties. The final count was fourteen; of the fourteen he knew of ten, of the ten only seven knew him, and of that seven there was one, the thirteenth, a girl her mother named Dawn, who carried the strange record of never falling ill a day in her life.
When other children got sick she examined them curiously and asked them to show her how to sneeze or cough. In her fifth year of primary school measles broke out, hitting everyone but her and Nicholas Chee, who had had it before. But this oddity wasn’t what made her stand out; rather, it was her performances in school. She excelled in every subject she took and after graduating from primary school moved on to one of the best secondary schools in the country. There she continued to outperform the others. It seemed her only match in intelligence existed, unfortunately, within her own family. Her half-brother would produce his report cards immediately after she produced hers and the smile on their mother’s face would stretch even wider.
They were only two years apart, Dawn and her brother, but they never really got along. When she was much younger, maybe seven or eight, he would tease her when their parents weren’t around, telling her she was lucky she was allowed to stay and live with them considering Daddy wasn’t her real daddy. She never really forgave him for that, even years later. There was a period, probably no more than a few months long, when she was thirteen and he was eleven, where she felt she had taken back all of the ground he had seized from her in earlier years with his idle comments. He had been singing his favorite song, over and over. This with a voice that had caused many adults to pause and comment on its arresting command. She grew irritated and her usual gentle temperament snapped. Standing a head higher than him and affecting the maturity of the elder, she cornered him. In the space of a few seconds, she complimented his singing and then lamented the fact that he would lose his ability to sing like that when he hit puberty and his voice broke. Anyway, she informed him, at least he wouldn’t sound like a little girl anymore. It might have been the undetectable malice she delivered it with or the fact that it was completely out of character and had been said with an earnestness that seemed genuine. Whatever it was, he stopped singing immediately before walking away, his face scrunched in conflicting emotion.
She herself was quite shocked about the impact it had on him. He became more apathetic, which their parents didn’t seem to notice, but the apathy was followed by plummeting school performances, which they did. This made their mother pay closer attention. So she noticed that every time he heard a song he liked and started singing he would suddenly stop himself and look around self consciously. The natural question was raised: Why? Dawn being present, figured she was moments away from being found out, but her brother simply shrugged as though he didn’t know. So their mother encouraged him gently to sing, and Dawn, feeling the relief of narrow escape, pondered the warring bloods within her and vowed in that moment to replace it with something more unifying. That period cast a whole new light on all her other relationships and all the relationships she wanted to have thereon. She found her first and only boyfriend in athletics training after school, two years before her secondary-level education ended, and devised a strategy to happen upon him on occasion when they were heading home. That went on until he took the opportunity to ask her for her phone number. What followed was months of running to the phone and breathlessly answering, just in case he was calling. A practice she continued until she got her first cellphone in university.
She studied chemical engineering, graduated, and got herself a job working in a petrochemicals plant. By that time she had managed to start the talk about marriage with her boyfriend, and four years later they moved into their new house together as a married couple. Her half-brother, whom she figured must have been deliberately competing to always better her, got married not more than a year later to an American woman whom he had met while living and working in the country.
Not long after the wedding, the family held its only reunion. It came at a bad time for her, however. She was pregnant, and although she had had the smoothest pregnancy imaginable, so far she disliked going anywhere she hadn’t been before or staying up longer than she needed to. Plus she had an ultrasound scheduled on the same day and didn’t like having to run around.
Her sister-in-law had met her only a few times before, but as she seemed to know no one else there besides Dawn and her own husband, she sought her out, asking her how many months along she was when the topic of her pregnancy came up. Dawn answered two months, and asked politely in return about her trip. She said that it had been fine. She had really enjoyed the ride up here, she continued, “You guys have really good roads,” as though she was expecting the dirt roads and old bison-drawn carts of years gone. Dawn was tired and a little annoyed, holding the knowledge of what she carried in her belly and not having the opportunity yet to discuss it fully with her husband, even though he was standing right next to her. Now he stepped in to answer her sister-in-law before she did, saving her from saying something she might later have regretted.
Heading home in their car after the reunion, she sat in the passenger seat, quietly cogitating on whether it was an advantage that they were not identical. It took her husband asking the question to break her from her thoughts, “You ain’ bring the results from the ultrasound?”
“It’ somewhere in the back there.”
“What the doctor say? I’s really quadruplets?”
“You think they would lie about that?”
“So i’s four boys or four girls?” he asked, staring ahead at the road ahead of him, simultaneously marveling and stressing at the thought of how one moment could lead to such uncontrollable multiplicity and how, at any given point, one person could contain such multitudes.
“No,” Dawn said, shaking her head and rubbing a hand over the bulge of her belly, “two boys and two girls.”
Darren Doyle is a writer originally from Trinidad and Tobago and now residing in the United Kingdom. His fiction investigates Caribbean identity and belonging. Shortlisted for the 2015 Commonwealth Short Story Prize and published in Susumba’s Book Bag and PREE. He is currently working on a series of short stories that bridge Trinidadian culture with global themes. For more, see darrendoyle.com.